Three pairs of curious eyes stared out at us from the short yellow bus coming to a stop in front of my neighbors’ driveway. The bus driver gave the horn two friendly toots and Phillip, my neighbor, shot out his front door, massive backpack swinging wildly from his person, and disappeared onto the bus. Mrs. Wright, Phil’s mom and neighborhood MILF, followed him out the door and halfway down the path waving goodbye. As she turned to go inside, she noticed us and yelled “Good morning,” bending down for the newspaper. Mom had been torturing me with her mandatory first-day-of-school photograph, this final one meant to join the dozen or so already marching down the hallway wall. She waved back to Mrs. Wright and crossed the lawn for a chat. I was excused.
The program for special needs kids in my high school was called Option Three. Upon gleaning this bit of trivia our freshman year, me and Ronnie, my best friend, posed the question to each other that if being retarded was the third option, what, pray tell, were the others? Tucked away on an inconspicuous bench in the courtyard every day at lunch we developed a system of classmate classification. It was very scientific.
Option Ones, Double O’s we liked to call them, were the superstars—gifted in some way or at least perky enough to fake it. The athletes, the cheerleaders, the bright, the enthusiastic, the joiners. As a rule, we hated Option Ones.
Option Twos were your regular kids just getting by. The guy in your shop class who hoped nobody noticed that he only had two pairs of jeans which he alternated throughout the week—blue, blue, black, blue, blue. Your frizzy haired lab partner with persistent milk breath. The fifth (out of five) chair flautist in the band who cried during geometry tests.
Mostly, we were surrounded by people of this stature. Despite being admittedly clever bastards, Ronnie and I couldn’t, in good faith, classify ourselves as anything other than Option Two. Ronnie was fat but, despite his girth, had a way of disappearing into his surroundings. People were always running into him and then looking up in shock, as if he was at fault for merely existing. And even though my parents had made the infinitely wise decision to hold me back in the first grade, I was still one of the smallest guys in my class. I’d never been a stellar student in anything, with the possible exception of drawing and some late-in-the-game success in math. I had oily hair and zits so bad I resented having to leave the house. Options Twos were our people.
Option Threes, like my neighbor Phil, rode the short bus. With the exception of having developed a gang sign, an upside-down “OK,” that we imagined them waving out the window of their dropped bus after drive-by shootings of rival O-Three programs, Ronnie and I generally ignored these kids. They kept to themselves, which insulated them from the majority of teasing going on. In our school, we observed, it was only when someone tried to cross the Option borders that kids got mean. The wiser of us could sense the underlying peacekeeping force at work and tried to stay content with our respective plots, hopeful that college, and in my case art school, would sort things out fairly and justly.
At least that was the feeling I had after that last first day of school. Ronnie and I were reading comic books over bowls of cereal when Mom got home from work that afternoon.
“How’d it go?” she asked excitedly, all but sitting down on Ronnie’s lap until she noticed him sitting there. She ruffled his hair as an apology.
So encouraged by my day, I actually answered her, “Fine.” I didn’t even growl my response so as to prevent further inquiry. Ronnie nodded in agreement as he slurped up his cocoa-tinted milk.
Mom began sifting through the pile of mail on the counter, then stopped in thought and pointed an envelope at me.
“Oh. Mrs. Wright asked if you’d be interested in tutoring Phil once or twice a week.”
My spoon clanged loudly when it fell out of my hand and into my bowl. I looked up at her in disbelief and, knowing he would be thoroughly enjoying this at my expense, avoided looking at Ronnie.
Phillip and I had been buddies as kids. Young kids. My family moved to the neighborhood when I was four, and even though I knew Phil was different, I never really cared because he was such a good time, always ready to laugh. We ran around the neighborhood like savages, pillaging the woods behind our subdivision.
It was only when he went to school full time that Phil was really separated from the rest of us. His parents spent all sorts of money testing his brain. Eventually, as far as I could tell, they decided he’d be better off being the smartest of the Threes rather than the stupidest of the regular kids. It was about the same time that my parents held me back a grade, but Phil and I were too young to process our feelings about it together. All I knew was that from then on he rode the short bus, and we stopped hanging out.
“I told her I thought it was a great idea,” Mom said, smiling at me, eyebrows raised in anticipated agreement. She never gave up hope that I’d one day wake up and not resent her existence.
“You’re kidding.”
“No. Phillip needs help in math. You’re good at math.”
“Mom. He’s retarded. Are you sure he even takes math?”
Her face was still giving me the benefit of the doubt. I hated her for it. At the same time, though, she knew what she was doing.
“Tim.” She liked to mimic my tone, especially in front of my friends. “He’s not retarded. He takes math.”
I exhaled dramatically. “Do I have to?” I finally looked to Ronnie to make sure that he was getting the record of my potential indentured servitude straight.
“Well, of course you don’t have to. But I think it’d be good for colleges to see something other than ‘Japanese anime expert’ on your applications this fall. Yours too,” she nodded at Ronnie. She picked up our bowls and took them to the sink.
“And it’d be nice for you to earn some money,” she added.
“They’d pay me?” The force was strong with this one.
She nodded over her shoulder. “And we should talk about those applications,” she said over the noise of the running water.
And with that my mood was dampened. The fact that she had no faith in my creative skills was one thing. She could be proven wrong. Revealing this in front of my best friend was something altogether different.
“I’ve got it covered,” I said, slinking off the bar stool, motioning to Ronnie that it was time to go. He followed me down the hall.
“Honey,” she called after me, “I just want you to keep your options open!”
The following Thursday night, having agreed to try the tutoring strictly out of monetary necessity, I knocked on the Wrights’ front door. I waited. When no one answered, I rang the bell and heard an annoyed voice from deep within the house yell “Mom.” A few seconds later Mrs. Wright, seemingly engulfed in the full glory of dinner preparations and never looking better, opened the door. She was wiping her hands on a dish towel and gestured me inside.
“Phil’s in his room. You can go on back.”
“Is his still the—”
“—first door on the right.”
“Right.”
I walked toward the familiar hall but was surprised to see that the Wrights had updated their family room furniture with these oversized modern couches and a huge TV. The last time I was here, their family room looked just like ours did and still does—beat up old sofas in itchy plaid fabric with a TV not even worth watching.
I knocked on Phil’s door.
“Come in already!” The voice was still annoyed.
I cautiously opened it.
Head buried in a text book, Phillip was sitting at the biggest desk I’d ever seen in a kid’s room. It wrapped around two walls and was covered in electronic equipment in various stages of disrepair. Model airplanes hung from every available inch of space on the ceiling, and he had the exact same poster that I had hanging over my bed on the wall above his. It was of a young Yasmine Bleeth, during her Baywatch years. I liked knowing that somewhere along the way, our appreciation of female television talent had developed in parallel even if our ability to critically read and write had not.
Phil stood up when he saw it was me.
“Oh. Sorry. I thought you were my mom. She’s driving me,” rolling his eyes for effect, “crazy.”
“Mine too.”
He moved some books off a chair and pulled it over next to his.
“Cool room,” I said, looking up at Yasmine.
“Thanks,” he said, following my gaze. A mischievous smile stretched across his face, and I noticed the sizable gap he used to have between his front teeth had been orthodontured out.
He sat back down at his desk, stared at his book, and immediately looked frustrated. I sat next to him and looked over his shoulder.
“So, what math are you in?” I asked.
“Pre-algebra. I hate it,” he said, drawing out the word “hate” and, again, rolling his eyes.
“Yeah, algebra’s a bitch. Who do you have?”
“Mr. Stevens.”
“Ah, he’s the worst. Everyone calls him Euclid.”
Phil stared blankly back at me. “Is that who you had?”
“Naw. I had Miss Dougherty, but my friend had Stevens and said he was a hard ass.”
“He’s OK,” he said, nervously looking away.
“Dude, did you hear about the time he passed out in the middle of a class?” I persisted.
Phil shook his head and looked slightly alarmed.
“It was a couple years ago. He just flops down in the middle of some lecture on variables or some shit, right in front of the board. So some cheerleader runs to the office for help, but no one knows what to do with him in the meantime, right? So this one guy, Gene Hunter, you know him, he bends down and crosses Mr. Stevens’ arms over his chest like he was dead. And they all just stand around in a circle looking down over him.”
Eyebrows raised in anticipated agreement that it was the best thing to ever happen in our young lives, I waited for the story to sink in. Phil didn’t think it was funny. When Ronnie recounted the event to me shortly after it happened, I laughed so hard I think I soiled myself.
Amidst the dozens of phone calls that Phillip received on his apparently private line over the course of the next hour, we went through his homework problems and a practice quiz at the end of the chapter. He answered each incoming call immediately, said a couple of cryptic words and then hung up sporting the same mischievous smile that Yasmine had seemed to induce.
When we had finished for the evening, I said good night to Mr. and Mrs. Wright, who were sitting at opposite ends of their fancy sofa watching the news. Mrs. Wright followed me out the front door and handed over a small white envelope.
“Thanks for coming tonight, Tim.”
“No problem,” I said, peeking into the envelope.
She looked around uneasily and lowered her voice.
“It would mean a lot to Larry and me if Phillip didn’t find out that we’re paying you for the tutoring,” she said, looking past me at her front door. “He still thinks of you two as friends, and,” her voice trailed off.
I instantly felt sorry for both her and Phil.
“Sure, Mrs. Wright. I’ll see you next Thursday,” I said, waving goodbye with the envelope. I walked across the grass to my house. My parents were sitting together on our crusty old couch. Mom looked up from her newspaper.
“How’d it go?”
“Classic,” Ronnie said, completely satisfied with himself. We were headed downstairs into B007, our school’s attempt at an artists’ grotto. Its windows looked out onto the baseline of the tennis courts, which, on windy days, provided even the most diligent of us with plenty of distraction in the form of the girls’ billowing short skirts.
“I told you the O-Threes fuck like rabbits. Brad Kennedy’s mom is the accountant for the Center for the Retarded, and he says that she says that they’re all on birth control because they’re all banging the shit out of each other.”
“Shut up, dude. Phillip’s not retarded.”
“Rabbits,” he demanded.
“It’s just a poster. I’m sure he’s not getting any,” I said with waning conviction.
“You need to find out what those calls were all about. I bet there was some nasty shit going down and you didn’t even know about it.”
“Whatever,” I said, settling in over the collection of ink drawings of which my portfolio was composed.
“O-Three girls aren’t inhibited like regular chicks, dude,” Ronnie said. “They’re down.”
I spent every afternoon that fall in B007 working on my portfolio and developing a quiet but profound crush on the backside of Mandy Evans, a junior and apparently new to our school. I didn’t know much, if anything, about her. She had a strong forehand, which alone probably made her Option One material, but I gave her the benefit of the doubt.
I spent most Thursday evenings with Phillip, each time accumulating more insight into his world. He had a nervous energy that manifested itself in repetition and, what felt like to me, chaos. Every night during the month of October, for example, we listened to “Hey Now, You’re an All Star” on repeat, and not really at a comfortable decibel level either. He wasn’t the jovial kid with whom I’d spent hours perched up in trees perfecting sound effects, everything from farts to incoming bullets. Instead he’d turned into some sort of parody of a teenager, like something he’d seen on television but wasn’t getting quite right.
One night late in the semester, when we were finished with his homework, Phil took me out to the garage to show me the old Mustang his dad had bought him to fix up. They had an agreement that if Phil could get a C average in all of his classes, they would let him take Driver’s Ed. He was getting close in Algebra but rolled his eyes when I asked about his other subjects. He was excited, though, because he would get to take shop the following semester and then really start working on the car.
“That’s cool,” I said and meant it. “My dad hasn’t gotten me shit.”
“But you have your license, right?”
“Yeah, but I don’t get to drive very often.” I ran my hand across the fender.
“But you can.”
“Yeah, I guess so.”
Phil moved around the car like he spent a lot of time with it. He opened the trunk to show me some of the tools his dad had given him for his birthday. He picked up a socket wrench out of the well-ordered collection and looked up at me, which he never did.
“Are you going to Winterfest?” he asked.
“Like, the dance?” I vaguely recalled our school having what I assumed to be the equivalent of a school-wide prom before winter break.
“Uh, no.”
Phil looked puzzled, disappointed. “Why not?”
It had never occurred to me to go to a school dance. “I don’t know, man. It’s just not my thing I guess.”
“Oh.” He looked hurt. I picked up a socket and put it on the end of my index finger.
“Why? Are you going?” I asked, almost afraid to hear the answer.
Phil swiveled the socket wrench around in his hand, the clicking noise filling the garage. “Maybe.”
That weekend I sequestered myself in my room in order to put the finishing touches on my portfolio for my priority schools’ early application deadlines, careful not to even acknowledge the stack of information from the junior colleges and shitty state schools that my parents had so thoughtfully amassed for me. Mom barged into my room holding the phone in her hand while I finished sealing the large yellow envelope that contained the entirety of my future well being and happiness.
“What?”
“It’s Mrs. Wright,” she said, handing me the phone.
I cleared my throat and said “Hello,” standing to close the door just in case it happened to be the day that Mrs. Wright demanded that I come over immediately so she could make a man of me yet. My mom’s foot in the doorway, however, impeded our privacy.
Phillip had told her that I had no big plans for the dance. “You see, Tim, Larry and I usually chaperone the dances, but Phillip, well, he really wants to do this one on his own, you know?” And would I mind escorting him and three friends, “just to keep an eye on things.” They would pay me, of course.
I couldn’t believe what I was hearing.
“Are you there, Tim?”
“Um, yeah, I’m here.” My voice cracked for the first time in a couple of years. “It’s just, I don’t really go to dances.” I looked up at Mom in the doorway, her face contorted to the look of “please don’t disappoint me by not being the man I know you can be” that she practices in the mirror every night to silently control me and Dad.
“But, OK, I guess so,” I agreed.
“No fucking way, dude.” Ronnie slammed his locker shut. “You’re insane for saying yes in the first place.”
“Dude, just do me this one favor. Please.”
“No. Way.” He shook his head at me like I was the Option Three. “One, I don’t go to dances. And two, definitely not with a bunch of retarded kids. Your shoe’s untied.”
I bent down to tie my shoe, and Ronnie clamped his hand on the back of my neck, holding me down. It was my own fault. We walked like that to second period.
Phil came over around 7:30 the following Saturday night. He was wearing a suit. I was in my standard uniform of jeans and a sweatshirt big enough to hide in. He helped me clean out the back of Mom’s station wagon before his best friend, Jason, arrived. He wasn’t retarded either, but I could tell that he was Option Three. He blinked incessantly, as if he was trying to forget some painful memory over and over again. He seemed relieved when his mom started to leave. She shook my hand, told us all to have fun and to be careful.
We stood around in the driveway drinking Dr Peppers, waiting for their dates. A shiny, camel colored Mercedes pulled up, and two girls, Leah and Cybil, got out of the back seat. Leah had very prominent gums but was otherwise normal looking. Cybil was extremely skinny and looked like she could use a bath. They rushed up to the guys and gave them each a hug. Apparently they were all “camp friends.”
We said goodbye to the Wrights and piled into the car, Phil in the front seat with me, Leah and Cybil flanking Jason in the back. Phil played with the radio while the girls chattered across Jason about what songs they were hoping to hear and who they were hoping would be there, a bunch of names I didn’t recognize. In the rearview mirror, Jason jovially looked back and forth between them, eyelids pressing tightly shut and releasing.
Hoping to keep a low profile, I pulled into the small parking lot on the side of the gym usually reserved for coaches or janitors. The backseat quickly emptied, but Phil stayed behind. When Jason had closed the door, Phil leaned over to me.
“Is your date meeting us here?”
“No, man. I don’t have one,” I said, maybe sounding a little defensive.
“No wonder you don’t like dances,” he said matter-of-factly, and hurried out of the car. He put his arm around Leah and waited for me to catch up.
I could hear Ronnie’s voice having a field day with the situation so made up some excuse to go to the bathroom so as not to enter my first, and what turned out to be my only, high school dance with a group of highly functioning special-ed kids. After spending enough time hidden within the safety of the handicapped stall without it looking like I was taking a massive shit, I took a deep breath and walked out of the bathroom.
I started down the hall toward the gym just behind a big pack of Option Ones. A girl in a short green sequined dress dropped her shiny gold purse on the floor. Having etched the shape of those legs into my mind, I quickly recognized them as Mandy’s. Her date noticed that she had stopped, but kept walking, announcing to his buddies in a poorly executed brogue, “Arrrgh, the leprechaun dropped her pot-o-gold!” Laughter erupted.
I bent down to pick up the bag at the same time she did, shaky on her high heels. She fell slightly into me and took the purse out of my hand.
She said “Thanks,” in what sounded like a sincere way. Up close I could smell beer on her breath, and her makeup made her look like a raccoon that had had a long night. She steadied herself with the help of my shoulder and pulled up her strapless dress. Then before turning to walk into the gym, she stared at me for a second, which made me self conscious about my skin.
“Sure,” I managed to say as we walked towards the gym. I opened the door for us. She made a beeline for something and disappeared into the crowd. The dance floor was buzzing, mostly populated by tight swarms of Option Ones suggestively grinding into each other.
I was almost relieved to see Phil and his crew standing to one side of the floor with a few other Option Threes. Phil saw me across the crowd and nodded but kept his arm around Leah. I casually walked over to him and asked if everything was OK. He said they were fine. Leah was gesticulating wildly as she recounted the story of how a “DS” had asked her to dance at her school’s homecoming.
I leaned into Phil and whispered, “What’s a DS?”
“Down Syndrome.” He rolled his eyes.
“Ah,” I nodded. I guess Ronnie and I had missed Option Four, the kids Option Threes make fun of.
I wandered around the gym, avoiding the dance floor, casually looking for signs of Mandy. I spilled Hawaiian Punch on my sweatshirt and had a seat on the bleachers and watched the room fill up. From a distance, Phil’s group looked like everyone else. They danced to the slow songs but mostly just stood around in the same spot trying to look like they were having fun.
The occasional female shrill could be heard over the loud music. When the first girl left the gym in tears, I made a mental to note to recount the occurrence in detail to Ronnie the following day. When the second girl left the gym in tears, I looked at my watch and decided I’d had enough.
Phil and his friends needed to take pictures before we left, so I waited next to the woman taking the money and watched the couples standing together in front of the wintry backdrop smiling nicely for posterity. The couples handed over checks for big packages of pictures that were to arrive by mail in six to eight weeks and then were stiffly posed together by the photographer.
Jason and Cybil then joined them for a group shot, but before the photographer could take the picture, Phil yelled my name, much louder than was required to be heard over the music, and waved me over to join them. I was caught off guard, like the photographer’s assistant had sucker punched me in the nuts.
I shook my head and said, “You guys go ahead! You look great!”
But Jason, Cybil, Leah, and even the photographer vehemently agreed and were all waving and yelling that I should come be in the picture. I looked around, certain that the whole gym was watching and realizing that the quiet guy in their homeroom class wasn’t just quiet but actually retarded, and good for him for making a B on that last math test, and at least he can draw pretty well. Mandy Evans was surely realizing that the little guy who had helped her with her purse has special needs and wasn’t that sweet of him. In the blur, though, I recognized only Milk Breath, also standing in the picture line, with a man who had to be in his thirties. Her usually frizzy hair was tamed into a stylish twist, and tucked into the side of her handsome felon, she looked happy, confident. She smiled at me.
I was shaking my head no but then looked up at Phillip, whose face had lost its merriment. My heart sank, and my balls retracted up into my throat. The group cheered as I stepped in front of the white sheet and took my place next to Phil, who promptly put his arm around my shoulder, merriment restored. I led the way out of the gym and into the cold night where two girls consoled another who was crying.
On the way home, we went to Sonic for cherry limeades, and the boys got to first base at Leah’s front door. I tried not to watch. When we got home the boys got out and said good night.
Taped to my front door was an envelope with my name on it. I was opening it as I walked in and found Mom sitting on the couch reading a book. She looked up at me.
“How’d it go?”
by Vicki Vaughn


